Showing posts with label Coal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Coal. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 09, 2009

Clean Coal?

Four Corners this week looked at the issue of 'clean' coal - also called Geosequestration or Carbon Capture and Storage (or CCS) or even 'burying the carbon pollution under the ground' - and whether it was a possible major part of any climate change solution.
.
Against clean coal was Mark Diesendorf (from the Institute of Environmental Studies at UNSW), who argued that the technology was: unproven; expensive; risky; and the money would be much better spent on already available renewable energy such as wind and solar.
.
Dr Joseph Romm was also interviewed. He argued that clean coal faced a number of challenges:
  • Expensive
  • Unproven
  • Risky
There were also pro-clean coal viewpoints put forward by the coal industry. I

nterestingly the program also had a look at the failed US attempt to get CCS technology 'off the ground' and working 'safely' (it faced increasing levels of community concerns). Given that any new technology must cross the technology 'valley of death' to get to market, it will be both difficult and expensive for Australia to succeed where the US is currently failing.
.
It needs a lot of Government funding and regulatory help. It is getting this at the State and Federal level, but given that the funding available here is relatively very small in size compared to the US (and they found it too expensive to get a demonstration plant running), it is a difficult task indeed.
.
The main question is: Could the money be better spent on other solutions?
.
Renewable energy is already available and needs further policy help to play a major part. The clean coal technology plant would have only lowered the carbon pollution emitted by the coal fired power station by 1.5%. Not a great reduction. "its the idea" said the coal spokesman. It would also take many years (decades even) to roll out any retrofit program for existing coal power stations. Dr Romm suggested we would also need to bury as much carbon pollution as we dill oil out of the ground each year.
.
Anyway, well worth a look.


Video available here


** If you enjoyed this post please also check out:


'Clean Coal' ???


EPA decides 'no new coal-fired power plants' (Well at least for now)


Greenpeace protests against coal carriers


Should coal-fired energy producers pay for greenhouse pollution permits???


Top 10 Environmental Posts



COMMENTS ALWAYS WELCOME !!

.
So please, tell us what you think.

Sunday, November 23, 2008

'Clean Coal' ???

I was reading an article called "Get paid for solar power on your roof" about Carmel Tebbutt (NSW Minister for Environment and Climate Change) announcing a "feed-in tariff" (i.e. they pay you for any energy you feed into the electricity grid from solar panels) in the environmental section of the Sydney Morning Herald, when I noticed the following click-on advertisment next to the solar energy newstory.


It looks like an advertisment to promote individual awareness about energy conservation - to turn off light-switches when not in use. But is it ?? Lets click on it and see what comes up . . .






Hmmm. . . .
.
I agree that everyone can 'do a little' - but I think we need to encourage people to do MORE about climate change.

Oh Geez, the Australian 'dirty' coal industry is trying to go green (I mean 'clean'). Much like the nucler industry is trying to go green by promoting itself as being 'safe' (laughing so hard, except it is not funny!!).

.

Gee, maybe I don't need to do anything if the Australian Coal industry is going to reduce its emissions by 'up to 90%) - wrong !! This taps into the 'I will leave it to someone else' or 'there is nothing I can do because I am too small' type thinking that is so common in our society when it comes to climate change.

.

Everyone may be worried, but many people just want someone else to 'do something'. This is a problem because people can do a LOT to help reduce the need for more coal power stations by reducing their individual carbon footprint. There are many ways for people to reduce their energy consumption (such as turning off lights when not in use, more efficient appliances, solar panels, gas rather than electric heating). The combined effect of everyone doing MORE will be a reduced need for more dirty coal power stations !!

.

Anyway, then this pops up

.


So I clicked on it to see what their website had to say. I was guessing 'clean coal' as the 'solution' and I was right. What was funnier, it had a place to "Ask an expert" a question related to "topics like low-emissions coal technology, coal's role in the Australian economy and the challenge of climate change".

.

One of my more deeper-green thinking friends believes that the idea of asking an 'expert' from the coal industry "what is the solution to climate change?" is like asking Charles Manson how to keep the streets safe. "Come on, where are most of the emissions coming from?? DIRTY COAL STATIONS !!"

.

Anyway, I asked their 'expert' about whether ecological modernisation i.e. “The dirty and ugly industrial caterpillar will transform into an ecological butterfly” (Huber, 1985) is the solution to climate change or if more ecocentric thinking was required.

.

I also asked if 'clean' coal was similiar to 'safe' nuclear energy.

.

I also asked the 'expert' if renewable energy (such as solar) and individual behaviour change were better options than dirty coal.

.

If the coal industry is pushing for a technocratic ecological modernisation approach (which it is), then it needs to realise that one of the main features of ecological modernisation is a change from top-down expert driven kowledge and decision making to bottom-up local knowledge and decision making. The coal industry needs to start listening to the community.

.

Yet here is the Australian Coal industry with "ask a coal industry expert'. Australian society increasingly wants renewable energy and real green jobs over dirty coal and its dirty brown jobs. Dirty coal has had its day.

Could the huge amounts of money being invested in clean coal by governments be better spent on renewables (which is also already available) or even environmental behaviour change programs such as Community Based Social Marketing?

.

What do you all think ????

For an alternative view to the coal industries - check out www.THISISREALITY.org

Saturday, November 15, 2008

EPA decides 'no new coal-fired power plants' (Well at least for now)


Here are some articles on the decision by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that it has no valid reason to refuse to regulate the CO2 emissions that come from new coal-powered plants.


The decision pointed to a May 2007 ruling by the Supreme Court that recognized CO2, the main cause of climate change, is indeed a pollutant under the federal Clean Air Act and therefore needs to be regulated by the EPA.


The board's decision will force the EPA to consider CO2 when issuing permits for new power plants, potentially making it — at least in the short-term — all but impossible to certify new coal power plants.






** If you enjoyed this post please also check out:


'Clean Coal' ???


Clean Coal?


Greenpeace protests against coal carriers


Should coal-fired energy producers pay for greenhouse pollution permits???


Top 10 Environmental Posts



COMMENTS ALWAYS WELCOME !!

.
So please, tell us what you think.

Monday, July 28, 2008

Greenpeace protests against coal carriers


Source: Fairfax Media

28 July 2008

Australian police have detained four Greenpeace activists after they painted 10 coal ships with anti-coal export slogans off the coast of Mackay in central Queensland.

The four people were in a group of nine protesters who approached the ships in three small inflatable boats early this morning, Greenpeace spokesperson Louise Clifton said.



The protest began about 6am and continued until a police boat arrived at the scene around 9.30am.

The green group is protesting the Queensland Government's plans to double coal exports in the next 20 years.

"The action was all about trying to highlight the contradiction between Prime Minister Rudd and Premier Bligh's stated intention to urgently reduce greenhouse pollution while presiding over a doubling of Australia's coal exports,"

Greenpeace campaigner Simon Roz said.

"Greenhouse pollution doesn't know any borders so coal burnt anywhere will be destroying pristine environments all around the globe including the Great Barrier Reef and the Murray Darling."

Queensland exports roughly 80 per cent of all coal mined in the state, according to a November 2007 report from the Department of Mines and Energy.

Coal exports are worth at least A$16 billion to the Queensland economy each year.

Sunday, June 15, 2008

Coal free by 2030: Greenpeace report

The World Today

16 June , 2008
Reporter: Sarah Clarke

ASHLEY HALL: Greenpeace says green renewable energy can be cheaper, cleaner, and create more jobs than fossil fuels.If embraced now, it could see the phasing out of coal use by 2030.In a report released today, the group says with the right recipe, 40 per cent of Australia's energy could be from a clean source within a decade.Here's environment reporter

Sarah Clarke:SARAH CLARKE: The report is titled "Australia's Energy Revolution", and not surprisingly, it found Australia has a lot of sun and wind. So much in fact, it declares that there's more than enough to power Australia's energy needs long-term. Professor Hugh Saddler who conducted the modelling says his findings are in fact conservative and in just over a decade, 40 per cent of Australia's electricity could be from a renewable source.

HUGH SADDLER: The resource is such that that's quite feasible and the companies that are involved with the various technologies certainly think that is achievable.

SARAH CLARKE: Hugh Saddler is a scientist specialising in energy needs, and using his modelling, he believes Australia could cut its carbon emissions from transport and energy by two-thirds by 2050. The recipe he uses is a large scale roll-out of electric vehicles, setting strict fuel efficiency standards to deliver more efficient cars and cutting aviation demands by improving rail networks. On electricity consumption, he says by enforcing simple efficiency measures, energy use could be reduced by 10 per cent in just over a decade. If this is achieved, Hugh Saddler says renewable power could adequately meet demand and the cost per household would in fact, be cheaper.

HUGH SADDLER: There is so much potential for increased energy efficiency which is cost effective even now, so that although the price per kilowatt hour for each unit of electricity consumed will be higher, the total cost of all the kilowatt hours that are consumed will be less because it's been used more efficiently.

SARAH CLARKE: And by embracing solar and wind, the report has found that coal-fired power stations could be phased out entirely by 2030.It's a bold recommendation, given the Federal Government is yet to legislate its target of 20 per cent of Australia's energy to be renewable by 2020. Even so, Julien Vincent from Greenpeace says this report shows it can be done, and what is in fact needed is the political will to take the next step.

JULIEN VINCENT: It's ridiculous that a country with enough renewable energy resources, it's now half of Asia, still bases its electricity supplies and 30 fossil fuels. And by increasing the amount of renewable energy in the mix, by driving energy efficiency quite significantly, we can start taking the dirtiest fossil fuels such as coal, off the grid.

ASHLEY HALL: Julien Vincent from Greenpeace, ending that report from Sarah Clarke.


http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/content/2008/s2275826.htm

Sunday, March 23, 2008

Should coal-fired energy producers pay for greenhouse pollution permits???

Compo call for coal-fired energy producers

Adam Morton
March 22, 2008
The Age

AUSTRALIA'S coal-fired energy industry has won the backing of business and the NSW Government in its campaign for massive compensation under Kevin Rudd's proposed laws to slash greenhouse gas emissions.

A heated debate is raging between the electricity generation industry and Government climate change adviser Ross Garnaut, after he argued high-polluting power stations did not deserve a handout to ensure they survived.

Under the professor's proposed carbon trading scheme, the Government would cap emissions and force all non-trade exposed industries, including the dirtiest power producers, to buy greenhouse pollution permits at auction.

The Victorian Employers' Chamber of Commerce and Industry said yesterday that the state's brown-coal reliant power stations should be compensated to "smooth the adjustment burden" of the new scheme.

Its chief economist, Steven Wojtkiw, supported many of Professor Garnaut's suggestions — including helping poor households hit by soaring electricity prices and developing "clean coal" technology — but said it was unclear whether power stations would keep operating without help.

The Victorian Government, which has supported compensation through a states-backed emissions taskforce, indicated it would consider Professor Garnaut's position.

But the NSW Government, facing the prospect of the value of its state-owned electricity industry tumbling while it is trying to privatise it, warned that the national electricity market would be destroyed if no compensation was offered. NSW Treasurer Michael Costa said power station owners had property rights that must be recognised. Federal Opposition sources said it was likely the Liberal Party would back Professor Garnaut's call to not directly compensate power generators.

Professor Garnaut says it is inevitable that household electricity bills will rise, and there is no proof that giving power generators free permits will keep them down. Carbon trading is due to start in 2010.

http://www.garnautreview.org.au

http://www.theage.com.au/news/environment/compo-call-for-coalfired-energy-producers/2008/03/21/1205602661781.html


Random Man says "dirty coal should pay for permits !!!!!"